DIRECTOR AID
WINDING-UP PETITION?

How to get a winding-up petition dismissed

Confidential help for company directors facing a winding-up petition. Your first consultation is free: you have nothing to lose.

Text DIRAID to 82228and we will call you back

Or call us on 07361 999123 or request a call back

No costNo obligationCompletely confidential
Director Aid crest FIRST CONSULTATION NOTHING TO LOSE FREE ★ ★
Director Aid is a private advisory service. We are not connected with the court, HM Courts & Tribunals Service, any petitioner or the Official Receiver.

Director Aid › Winding-up petitions

The court dismisses a winding-up petition on five grounds: the debt and the petitioner's costs have been paid in full; the debt is disputed on genuine and substantial grounds; the company has a cross-claim that equals or exceeds the debt; the petitioner has failed to comply with the Rules in a way the court will not overlook; or the petition is an abuse of process. Payment produces a dismissal by consent or a withdrawal with the court's permission; the other grounds have to be proved by the company's evidence, filed and served at least five business days before the hearing. A petition is not dismissed because the company turns up and says the debt is wrong. It is dismissed because the company shows the court, in time and in writing, why it should be.

Want the petition dismissed? Free initial consultation with a Solicitor: call 07361 999123 or text DIRAID to 82228.

Your free call is with a Solicitor. Have the petition to hand if you can.

Text DIRAID to 82228and we will call you back

Or call us on 07361 999123

First consultation free · No obligation · Nothing to lose

Dismissal and withdrawal

A petition ends short of a winding-up order either by being dismissed by the court at a hearing, or by being withdrawn by the petitioner with the court's permission, which before advertisement can be obtained without a hearing if the application is made at least five business days before the hearing and no other creditor has given notice. For the company the effect is the same: the petition is at an end, the bank lifts its freeze on sight of the sealed order, and section 127 no longer hangs over the company's payments.

1. The debt is paid in full, with costs

The most common ground, and the only one that does not depend on the court's view of the merits. Pay the petition debt, interest where claimed and the petitioner's costs, and the petitioner either applies to withdraw or asks the court at the hearing to dismiss the petition by consent.

Three cautions. Payment from the company's own account after presentation is void if a winding-up order is later made, so pay from a director's or a third party's funds where possible. Agree in writing, before paying, that the petitioner will seek dismissal or withdrawal and will not advertise meanwhile. And if another creditor has given notice of support, it can ask to be substituted and carry the petition on. See paying the debt.

2. A genuine and substantial dispute

A winding-up petition is a remedy for a company that cannot pay its debts, not a way of collecting a debt the company says it does not owe. Where the debt is disputed on genuine and substantial grounds the court will usually dismiss the petition and leave the petitioner to sue in the ordinary way. The company does not have to prove it will win; it has to show a real dispute, with substance, that existed before the petition and can be seen in the documents: the complaint about the goods or the work, the rejected invoice, the correspondence refusing payment and saying why. A dispute first raised in the company's witness statement, with nothing earlier to support it, is viewed with suspicion. Where only part of the debt is disputed and the undisputed part is more than £750, the petition usually proceeds on that part unless it is paid. See can I stop a petition if the debt is disputed?

3. A cross-claim exceeding the debt

Where the debt itself is not disputed but the company has a genuine claim against the petitioner that equals or exceeds it, for example for losses caused by the petitioner's defective performance of the same contract, the court may dismiss the petition rather than wind the company up while the net position is unresolved. The cross-claim must be genuine, quantified, and preferably raised before the petition. See the petitioner owes us money too.

4. Procedural failures by the petitioner

The Insolvency (England and Wales) Rules 2016 set out what a petitioner must do, and a failure can lead to dismissal. In practice the court's usual response to a curable failure is an adjournment to let the petitioner put it right, and the company should expect that rather than rely on a technicality.

Failure What the court usually does
Petition not served properly (wrong address, no attempt at the registered office, no order for substituted service) Adjourns for proper service, unless the company has in fact had the petition and suffered no prejudice. Dismissal is unusual. See I was never served with the petition.
No certificate of compliance filed at least five business days before the hearing May dismiss, but more often adjourns so that the certificate can be filed.
Advertised too early (before seven business days after service) or too late (less than seven business days before the hearing) May dismiss, or adjourn and direct re-advertisement. Premature advertisement is treated more seriously because of the damage it causes.
Petitioner does not attend May dismiss, but another creditor who has given notice can ask to be substituted and carry the petition on. See what happens if the petitioner does not turn up?
Debt below £750 or no proper basis for the company's inability to pay Dismissal, since the statutory ground is not made out.

Procedural points are worth taking, and a petitioner who has ignored the Rules may be ordered to pay the costs of the adjournment, but they are rarely enough on their own. Take them alongside a substantive ground, not instead of one.

5. Abuse of process

Where the petition has been presented for a purpose other than the winding-up of a company that cannot pay its debts, most commonly as a pressure tactic over a debt the petitioner knows to be disputed, the court can dismiss it as an abuse of process and may order the petitioner to pay the company's costs on a higher basis. The evidence is usually the correspondence showing the petitioner knew of the dispute and petitioned anyway. Before advertisement, the same material supports an urgent injunction application; see an injunction to restrain a winding-up petition.

The company's evidence

Except where the petition is dismissed by consent after payment, the company has to prove its ground. It does so by a witness statement, usually from a director, filed at court and served on the petitioner at least five business days before the hearing. The statement sets out the facts relied on and exhibits the documents: the contract, the invoices, the complaints, the correspondence, the calculation of any cross-claim, and anything showing the petitioner knew of the dispute. A statement filed late may not be read, and a company that attends with nothing filed is usually treated as not opposing.

The statement carries a statement of truth and should be prepared with a solicitor: an overstated or inconsistent statement damages a good case. How the hearing runs is in how to defend a winding-up petition.

Costs

A company that has the petition dismissed on the merits can seek its costs from the petitioner, and the court usually orders them, assessed if not agreed. Where the petition is dismissed because the company paid, the company usually pays the petitioner's costs as part of the settlement. Where the company opposes and fails, it is usually ordered to pay the petitioner's costs of the opposition. See how much a petition costs, and who pays.

Key points

  • Five grounds: payment in full with costs, genuine and substantial dispute, cross-claim exceeding the debt, procedural failure, abuse of process.
  • Payment leads to dismissal by consent or withdrawal by permission; the other grounds must be proved by evidence filed and served at least five business days before the hearing.
  • A dispute or cross-claim never raised before the petition is treated with suspicion; the documents from before the petition carry the weight.
  • Procedural failures usually produce an adjournment to cure, not a dismissal.
  • A company that succeeds on the merits can seek its costs; one that opposes and fails usually pays the petitioner's.

Frequently asked questions

Can the petition be dismissed before the hearing? Where the company applies for an injunction restraining advertisement on the ground of a genuine dispute, the court can dismiss the petition at that application. Otherwise dismissal happens at the hearing.

The petitioner has not filed a certificate of compliance. Will the petition be dismissed? It can be, but the court usually adjourns to allow the certificate to be filed. Do not rely on it.

Who pays the costs if the petition is dismissed? Where it is dismissed because the debt was genuinely disputed or the petition was an abuse, usually the petitioner. Where it is dismissed because the company paid, usually the company.

Tell us what is happening

Your first consultation is free, with no obligation: you have nothing to lose. Give us a few details and we will call you back. Everything you tell us is confidential.

Sorry, that didn't send. Please check your name, company and a phone number or email, and try again, or call 07361 999123.

We use these details only to contact you about your enquiry. See our privacy notice. Prefer to talk now? Call 07361 999123 or text DIRAID to 82228.

FIRST CONSULTATION NOTHING TO LOSE FREE ★ ★

Your first consultation is free.

Book a 30-minute phone call at a time that suits you, weekdays between 10am and 4pm, and we will call you. Or email us with your company name and, if you have it, the petition's case number.

Text DIRAID to 82228and we will call you back

Or call us on 07361 999123

help@directoraid.co.uk

Everything you tell us is treated in confidence.