Often, yes. A winding-up petition is not the right way to pursue a debt that is genuinely disputed on substantial grounds. The company can apply to the court to stop the petition being advertised and to have it dismissed, and the petitioner may be ordered to pay the costs. The dispute must be real and supported by evidence, and the application should be made quickly.
Think the debt isn't owed? Call 07361 999123 for a free initial consultation today.
Your free call is with a Solicitor. Have the petition to hand if you can.
Text DIRAID to 82228and we will call you back
Or call us on 07361 999123
First consultation free · No obligation · Nothing to lose
What counts as a genuine dispute
- The goods or services were defective, late or not supplied.
- The amount claimed is wrong or was never agreed.
- The invoice relates to a contract the company disputes.
- The debt has already been paid, in full or in part.
- The company has a genuine cross-claim against the creditor worth at least as much as the debt.
A dispute raised for the first time after the petition, with no paper trail, is much weaker than one raised promptly at the time.
Watch the undisputed balance
If part of the debt is not disputed and that part is enough on its own to found a petition, the dispute over the rest may not help. Check how much of the claim is truly contested.
How to challenge the petition
- Gather the evidence: contracts, emails, complaints, payment records and anything showing the dispute existed before the petition.
- Write to the petitioner: explain the dispute and ask it to withdraw, warning that the company will apply to the court otherwise.
- Apply to the court: for an injunction stopping advertisement and an order dismissing the petition, supported by a witness statement.
- Seek costs: where the dispute was clear, the petitioner may be ordered to pay the company's costs.
Why timing matters
An application made before advertisement can prevent the bank freeze and the publicity that follows. After advertisement, the damage is harder to undo.

From The Winding-Up Petition Handbook, free for directors.
Key points
- A genuinely disputed debt should not found a petition.
- The dispute must be substantial and supported by evidence.
- A genuine cross-claim can count.
- An undisputed balance may still be enough for a petition.
- Apply before the advertisement date.
Frequently asked questions
What if I just think the amount is too high? That may be enough if there is a real basis for it, but the undisputed part matters.
Can I get my costs back? Where the court finds the debt was genuinely disputed, the petitioner is often ordered to pay the company's costs.
Should I have challenged the statutory demand? A company cannot apply to set aside a statutory demand in the way an individual can, but it can apply to the court for an injunction restraining the creditor from presenting a petition at all. Once a petition has been presented, the application is to restrain advertisement and dismiss it. Either way, act as soon as the demand arrives.
Disputed debt? Act before the advert. Free initial consultation: 07361 999123 or request a call back.
