DIRECTOR AID
WINDING-UP PETITION?

How do we dispute a statutory demand against our company?

Confidential help for company directors facing a winding-up petition. Your first consultation is free: you have nothing to lose.

Text DIRAID to 82228and we will call you back

Or call us on 07361 999123 or request a call back

No costNo obligationCompletely confidential
Director Aid crest FIRST CONSULTATION NOTHING TO LOSE FREE ★ ★
Director Aid is a private advisory service. We are not connected with the court, HM Courts & Tribunals Service, any petitioner or the Official Receiver.

Director Aid › Winding-up petitions

Write to the creditor at once setting out why the debt is disputed, with the documents, and ask for a written undertaking not to present a winding-up petition; if the creditor will not give one, the company can apply to the court for an injunction restraining the petition. A company cannot apply to set a statutory demand aside: that procedure exists only for individuals. The dispute has to be genuine and on substantial grounds, and it is far more convincing raised now than after a petition arrives. See also disputed debts and winding-up petitions.

Disputing a demand? Run it through the free statutory demand checker first, then call 07361 999123 for a free initial consultation with a Solicitor.

Your free call is with a Solicitor. Have the petition to hand if you can.

Text DIRAID to 82228and we will call you back

Or call us on 07361 999123

First consultation free · No obligation · Nothing to lose

Why a company cannot set a demand aside

An individual served with a statutory demand can apply to the court to set it aside within 18 days. There is no equivalent for a company. The demand is simply the creditor's evidence that the company cannot pay its debts. The company's protection is that a winding-up petition is not the place to resolve a genuine dispute about a debt: if the debt is disputed in good faith and on substantial grounds, the court will usually restrain or dismiss a petition based on it, and the creditor risks paying the company's costs.

What makes a dispute "genuine and substantial"

What does not count: being unable to pay, a wish for more time, a complaint raised for the first time after the demand, or a dispute about a small part of a much larger debt that is otherwise owed (pay the undisputed part).

The letter to the creditor

Send it to the contact named in the demand within days, not at the end of the three weeks (see when to respond to a statutory demand). It should:

  1. Identify the demand (its date and the sum).
  2. Say whether the whole debt or part is disputed, and pay or offer the undisputed part.
  3. Set out the reasons, briefly and factually, with the key documents attached.
  4. Ask for a written undertaking, by a stated date before the three weeks end, that the creditor will not present a winding-up petition on the disputed debt.
  5. Say that if no undertaking is given the company will apply to the court for an injunction and seek its costs.

Keep it factual. The court may read it later.

The injunction

If the creditor will not give an undertaking, the company can apply to the court for an injunction restraining the creditor from presenting a winding-up petition (or, if one has been presented, from advertising it). The demand must name the court the company should apply to: usually the High Court, or for a company with paid-up share capital of no more than £120,000, the County Court hearing centre with insolvency jurisdiction for the registered office. The application is supported by a witness statement setting out the dispute and the documents. See injunction to restrain a winding-up petition.

DO NOT wait for a petition to be presented before acting if the creditor has said it will petition. Once a petition is advertised the bank usually freezes the account, whatever the merits of the dispute.

If only part is disputed

Pay the part that is owed, from funds that are not at risk, and dispute the rest. If the undisputed part alone is more than £750 and unpaid, the creditor can petition on that part, and the dispute about the rest will not help.

Key points

  • A company cannot set aside a statutory demand; that procedure is only for individuals.
  • Dispute the debt in writing at once, with documents, and ask for an undertaking not to petition.
  • A genuine dispute on substantial grounds, or a genuine cross-claim at least equal to the debt, is the test.
  • If no undertaking is given, the company can apply for an injunction restraining the petition.
  • Pay any undisputed part: if it is more than £750, it can found a petition on its own.

Frequently asked questions

Can a company apply to set aside a statutory demand? No. Only individuals can. A company disputes the debt in writing and, if necessary, applies for an injunction to stop a petition.

What if the creditor ignores our dispute and petitions anyway? The company can apply for the petition to be restrained or dismissed, and a creditor that petitions on a genuinely disputed debt risks paying the company's costs.

Does a counterclaim stop a statutory demand? A genuine and serious cross-claim at least equal to the debt can justify restraining a petition, in the same way as a disputed debt.

How quickly should we dispute it? Within days. A dispute raised for the first time near or after the end of the three weeks is treated with more suspicion.

Tell us what is happening

Your first consultation is free, with no obligation: you have nothing to lose. Give us a few details and we will call you back. Everything you tell us is confidential.

Sorry, that didn't send. Please check your name, company and a phone number or email, and try again, or call 07361 999123.

We use these details only to contact you about your enquiry. See our privacy notice. Prefer to talk now? Call 07361 999123 or text DIRAID to 82228.

FIRST CONSULTATION NOTHING TO LOSE FREE ★ ★

Your first consultation is free.

Book a 30-minute phone call at a time that suits you, weekdays between 10am and 4pm, and we will call you. Or email us with your company name and, if you have it, the petition's case number.

Text DIRAID to 82228and we will call you back

Or call us on 07361 999123

help@directoraid.co.uk

Everything you tell us is treated in confidence.