# Preferences and transactions at an undervalue: can a liquidator make me pay back money taken out before liquidation?

Source: https://directoraid.co.uk/preference-undervalue-claims-directors.html · Last reviewed 2026-11-20 · Director Aid

**Yes, if the payment or transfer falls within the rules. A liquidator or administrator can ask the court to reverse a payment that preferred one creditor in the six months before insolvency (two years if the creditor was a director or other connected person), and a sale or gift at an undervalue in the two years before. Directors are often the ones who benefited, and the ones who must repay.** Directors also ask "what is a preference payment in liquidation?", "can I repay my director's loan before the company goes into liquidation?" and "what is a transaction at an undervalue?". This page explains what counts, how far back the liquidator looks, the defences, and what to do before an insolvency practitioner reviews the books.

### The two claims in one table

| | Preference (section 239 Insolvency Act 1986) | Transaction at an undervalue (section 238) |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Putting a creditor or guarantor in a better position than they would have had in an insolvent liquidation | A gift, or a deal in which the company received significantly less than it gave |
| Look-back period | 6 months before the onset of insolvency; 2 years if the person preferred is connected with the company | 2 years before the onset of insolvency, for anyone |
| Insolvency at the time | Must be shown: the company was unable to pay its debts then, or became so because of the payment | Must be shown, but presumed if the other party is connected with the company |
| State of mind | The company must have been influenced by a desire to prefer; presumed if the person preferred is connected | Not required |
| Main defence | No desire to prefer: real commercial pressure, or a payment needed to keep trading | The company acted in good faith to carry on its business, with reasonable grounds for believing it would benefit |

"Connected" people include the company's directors and shadow directors, their close family, and companies in the same group or under common control. An employee is not connected merely by being employed.

### When the clock starts

The look-back period runs back from the **onset of insolvency**, which depends on the procedure:

- **Compulsory liquidation:** the date the winding-up petition was presented. A petition presented today fixes the start of the period, even though the order may come weeks later.
- **Creditors' voluntary liquidation:** the date of the shareholders' resolution to wind up.
- **Administration:** the date the court application was made, or the notice of intention to appoint was filed, or (otherwise) the date the appointment took effect.

That is how a winding-up petition connects to these claims. Once a petition has been presented, any further payment out of the company's property is also caught by a separate and stricter rule: it is void if a winding-up order follows, unless the court validates it (section 127). See [validation orders and section 127](https://directoraid.co.uk/validation-order-section-127.html).

### What a preference looks like in practice

The commonest preferences a liquidator finds involve directors:

- **Repaying a director's loan** to the company while other creditors go unpaid.
- **Paying off a bank overdraft or loan the director has personally guaranteed**, which reduces the director's own exposure under the guarantee. The guarantor is treated as a person preferred.
- **Paying a supplier owned by a relative** or a company under the same control.
- **Granting security** to an existing creditor, for example a charge in favour of a director who has lent money.

Payments to ordinary trade creditors are less often challenged, because the company must have been influenced by a desire to prefer them, and that is not presumed. Paying a supplier because it would otherwise stop supply, or under real pressure, is usually a commercial decision, not a preference.

### What an undervalue looks like in practice

- Selling a company van, equipment or stock to a director or a new company below its market value.
- Transferring the business, customer list or goodwill to a new company for little or nothing.
- Paying a dividend, bonus or "consultancy fee" for which the company received nothing.
- Releasing a debt owed to the company.

The test is the value the company received against the value it gave, at the time. A sale at a proper, independent valuation, with the price actually paid, is the best protection. Where the buyer is connected, the company's insolvency at the time is presumed, so the director must show it was solvent if that is the defence.

### What the court can order

The court can make any order it thinks fit to restore the position to what it would have been if the transaction had not happened. It can order the person who benefited to repay money or return property, release or re-impose security, and **revive a guarantee** that was reduced or discharged by a preferential payment. A director who personally guaranteed the bank debt that was paid off can find the guarantee reinstated as well as being asked to repay.

Separately, a transaction entered into to put assets beyond creditors' reach can be challenged under section 423, which has no fixed look-back period and does not require the company to be insolvent at the time. A director who caused the company to make a preference or undervalue sale can also face a misfeasance claim for breach of duty. See [can a liquidator sue me as a director?](https://directoraid.co.uk/defending-a-liquidators-claim-against-a-director.html).

### Disqualification

Preferences and transactions at an undervalue are among the matters the Insolvency Service considers when deciding whether a director's conduct makes them unfit. Paying yourself, or creditors you have guaranteed, ahead of HMRC and trade creditors in the months before insolvency is a frequent feature of disqualification cases. See [can I be disqualified after liquidation?](https://directoraid.co.uk/director-disqualification-compulsory-liquidation.html).

### What to do now

If the company is still trading but may be insolvent:

1. **Stop and take advice before any payment to yourself, a connected person or a creditor you have guaranteed.** Your duties now look first to the creditors as a whole. See [directors' duties when the company is insolvent](https://directoraid.co.uk/directors-duties-insolvent-company.html).
2. **DO NOT repay your own loan account, take security for it, or pay down a guaranteed overdraft ahead of other creditors while the company cannot pay its debts.**
3. **DO NOT sell or transfer assets to yourself or a new company without an independent valuation, and full payment at that value.**
4. Minute the reasons for significant payments: why they were needed to keep trading, and the advice taken.

If the company is already in liquidation or administration:

1. Expect the office-holder to review bank statements for the look-back period; connected payments are the first thing checked.
2. If you receive a letter about a payment, take advice before replying, and gather the records showing why it was made and the company's position at the time.
3. Check for directors' and officers' insurance and notify the insurer.
4. Consider whether repayment or settlement is cheaper than defending a claim: many claims settle once both sides have seen the documents.

### How often petitions end in liquidation

Every compulsory liquidation begins with a winding-up petition, usually a creditor's, and around six in ten advertised petitions are followed by a winding-up order ([Director Aid Petition Figures](https://directoraid.co.uk/what-proportion-of-winding-up-petitions-end-in-a-winding-up-order.html)). When that happens the petition date becomes the onset of insolvency, and the Official Receiver or liquidator looks back from it. A director who has been served with a petition should assume every payment from that point back will be examined. See [how to stop a winding-up petition](https://directoraid.co.uk/how-to-stop-a-winding-up-petition.html) and [what happens to directors in liquidation](https://directoraid.co.uk/what-happens-to-directors-in-liquidation.html).

![The exposure ladder: how far a director's personal liability can reach.](https://directoraid.co.uk/handbook-diagram-exposure-ladder.png)
*From [The Winding-Up Petition Handbook](https://directoraid.co.uk/winding-up-petition-handbook.html), free for directors.*

### Key points

- A liquidator or administrator can ask the court to reverse preferences and transactions at an undervalue.
- The look-back period is 6 months for a preference, or 2 years if the person preferred is connected, and 2 years for an undervalue.
- In a compulsory liquidation the look-back runs from the date the winding-up petition was presented.
- Desire to prefer is presumed for directors and other connected people, so repaying your own loan or a guaranteed overdraft is the classic risk.
- The court can order repayment and revive a director's personal guarantee; the same facts can support disqualification.

### Frequently asked questions

**What is a preference payment in liquidation?** A payment or other step that puts one creditor, or a guarantor, in a better position than they would have had in an insolvent liquidation, made when the company could not pay its debts and influenced by a desire to prefer them.

**Can I repay my director's loan before the company goes into liquidation?** Not safely if the company is insolvent. A repayment to a director within two years before the onset of insolvency can be reversed as a preference, and the desire to prefer is presumed.

**What is a transaction at an undervalue?** A gift, or a deal in which the company received significantly less value than it gave, within two years before the onset of insolvency, at a time when the company was unable to pay its debts.

**Can a liquidator claim back payments made to suppliers?** Rarely, unless the supplier is connected. For an ordinary supplier the liquidator must prove the company was influenced by a desire to prefer it, and paying to keep supplies flowing is usually a commercial decision.

---
Free initial consultation for directors facing a winding-up petition: text DIRAID to 82228, phone 07361 999123, email help@directoraid.co.uk, or book at https://calendly.com/directoraid/consultation.
