# Can another creditor take over the petition if I pay the first one?

Source: https://directoraid.co.uk/another-creditor-taking-over-the-winding-up-petition.html · Last reviewed 2026-10-24 · Director Aid

**Yes. It is called substitution, and it is the main reason paying the petitioner does not always end the petition.** A creditor that is owed money and has given notice of intention to appear at the hearing can ask the court to be substituted as petitioner where the original petitioner has been paid, wants to withdraw, or does not turn up. The petition then continues in the new creditor's name, with the same presentation date, so section 127 still runs from the original presentation.

### How it happens

1. The petition is advertised. Any creditor can now give notice, by 4pm on the business day before the hearing, that it intends to appear and support the petition.
2. The company pays the original petitioner, who tells the court it does not wish to proceed.
3. A supporting creditor asks to be substituted. The court will usually allow it where that creditor could itself have presented a petition, which means an undisputed debt that the company is not paying.
4. The petition continues. The company is back where it started, minus the money it paid the first creditor.

### Why it matters before you pay

Paying the petitioner from company funds that turn out to be void under section 127, only for another creditor to take the petition over and an order to follow, is the worst outcome of all. Before paying, find out who else is owed and whether anyone has given notice; deal with them too, or the payment buys nothing. In the Handbook's third worked example, a tyre supplier owed £9,200 gives notice and has to be paid alongside the petitioner.

### Before advertisement

Substitution needs a creditor who knows about the petition, and before advertisement very few do. A petition paid and withdrawn by permission before the advertisement date leaves nothing for anyone to take over. That is the window to use.

### What to do now

1. List every creditor who is owed money the company is not paying.
2. Ask the petitioner's solicitors whether any notices of intention to appear have been received.
3. Deal with the petitioner and any supporting creditors together, in writing, before paying anyone.
4. Get the order dismissing the petition or permitting withdrawal and send it to the bank.

### Where this is covered in more depth

[Paying the debt](https://directoraid.co.uk/pay-debt-stop-winding-up-petition.html), the Handbook's [Chapter 8](https://directoraid.co.uk/handbook-8-paying-the-debt.html) and the glossary entry for [substitution](https://directoraid.co.uk/glossary-substitution.html).

---
Free initial consultation for directors facing a winding-up petition: text DIRAID to 82228, phone 07361 999123, email help@directoraid.co.uk, or book at https://calendly.com/directoraid/consultation.
